The short answer: sometimes, and usually for more than one reason
If the drink sits still and everything else is matched, a thicker drink can slow the melting of an ice cube you add to it. Melting depends on warmer liquid reaching the ice surface, and a viscous liquid resists that flow. But when you compare two real drinks, thickness is rarely the only difference. Starting temperature, dissolved sugar and salt, and ice crystals already in the drink can matter more. Stirring can also cancel much of the viscosity effect.
So the honest answer is conditional. To find out what is happening in your glass, measure how much of the added cube is left, not how watery the drink tastes. (This article is about the drink, not the ice. Comparisons between ice shapes are a separate question.)
What happens to a cube in a still milkshake

Picture a thick milkshake in a glass on the counter. You drop one cube on top and leave it alone.
Melting takes a lot of energy. According to NIST's measurements of the latent heat of fusion of ice, each gram of ice absorbs roughly 334 joules just to change from solid to liquid, without getting any warmer. All of that heat has to come from the shake, and it can only enter the cube at its surface.
The cube's surface stays cold. The meltwater it releases and the shake right next to it both get chilled. In a thin drink, that cold liquid moves away and warmer liquid replaces it. The University of Illinois Physics Van describes the alternative in its explanation of ice melting in water and oil. Cold liquid that stays next to the ice "creates a blanket of unmoving fluid," while running warmer water past the ice makes it melt more quickly. The same answer notes that more viscous liquids resist flow, which slows the transfer of heat.
A milkshake is a good example of that blanket. The liquid around the cube moves slowly, so the cold layer stays in place longer. Heat still gets through, but more of it has to travel by conduction across a thin, cold layer, and less is carried in by moving liquid.
Why thickness weakens circulation
Physicists describe this kind of temperature-driven flow with the Rayleigh number. As the University of Maryland's Rayleigh-Bénard convection page explains, it depends on the temperature difference, gravity, the height of the fluid layer, the fluid's thermal diffusivity, and its viscosity. Viscosity sits on the side that pushes the number down. A lower Rayleigh number means weaker convection. Below a threshold of about 1,708 for the classic heated-layer setup, heat moves by conduction alone.
A glass of milkshake is not that textbook setup, but the direction carries over. More viscosity means less convection. The formula also includes layer height, so the shape and depth of the glass affect the flow too. That matters when you design a comparison.
What this does not tell you
The Physics Van is careful here. In a separate answer on melting and viscosity, it notes that it's hard to change a water solution's viscosity without changing other properties that affect melting. Those include the total amount of dissolved material, which shifts the melting temperature, and density, which decides whether meltwater sinks, floats, or mixes. Its conclusion that a low-viscosity solution probably melts ice faster "because it allows faster convective stirring" is offered as a reasoned guess, not a measured result. The mechanism is well established, but the size of the effect in a real milkshake hasn't been pinned down here, so treat the direction as reasoning rather than a measured number.
Three things that look like thickness
When a cube lasts longer in a shake than in juice, it's tempting to credit the thickness. In practice, three other differences usually come along with it.
1. A colder starting temperature
A milkshake made with ice cream often starts colder than a poured drink, and a colder drink has less heat to give the cube. The Institute of Culinary Education's guide to ice cream explains why ice cream stays scoopable well below 0 °C. Only pure water freezes, so the remaining mix gets more concentrated and its freezing point keeps dropping. At about 3 °F (−16 °C), only about 72% of the water in a typical base is frozen. A shake blended from that starts cold, and a cube in it may barely melt at first for reasons that have nothing to do with viscosity.
2. Dissolved ingredients
Sugar and salt change melting even when they barely change thickness. In a Physics Van answer on why ice melts faster in tap water than in salt water, dyed freshwater cubes melted in about half the time in tap water as in salt or sugar water. The explanation given is layering. In tap water, the cold meltwater sinks and sets up circulation. In a denser solution, the cold, fresh meltwater floats on top and sits against the cube, with little mixing below. That is a density and layering effect, not a viscosity effect, and a reader comment on the same page questions parts of the explanation. The takeaway is that dissolved ingredients can change the flow around the cube by themselves. For more on the sweet-drink side, see why ice in sweet drinks can seem to melt faster than in plain water.
3. Ice crystals already in the drink
A shake made from ice cream, frozen fruit, or blended ice already contains small ice crystals. They absorb heat as they melt, which leaves less for your added cube. They also add water to the drink as they melt, which is one reason the drink can taste thinner over time even while the added cube looks almost untouched.
Protein shake versus juice: not a clean test
A common kitchen comparison is a protein shake against a glass of juice. It feels like thick versus thin, but these are categories, not recipes.
| Protein shake | Juice | |
|---|---|---|
| Thickness | Depends on the recipe. Powder shaken with water can be fairly thin. Blended with frozen fruit, yogurt, or ice, it can be very thick. | Usually thin, though pulp and nectar styles vary. |
| Starting temperature | Blended with frozen ingredients, it may start near or below freezing. Shaken from the tap, it may start at room temperature. | Often straight from the fridge, but this depends on the household. |
| Dissolved ingredients | Varies with the powder, sweetener, and milk. | Often high in natural sugars. |
| Ice crystals already present | Present if it's blended with ice or frozen fruit. | Usually none, unless it's slushy. |
If the cube survives longer in the shake, any of those rows could explain it. Two protein shakes can differ from each other more than one of them differs from juice. Before blaming viscosity, write down what's in each glass and take each drink's temperature.
How to set up a matched comparison

To test thickness itself, change one thing and hold everything else as steady as you can.
- Starting temperature. Measure both drinks with the same thermometer just before adding ice, and wait until they read the same. If one drink is blended with frozen ingredients, let it warm or chill the other until they match.
- Ice mass and size. Use cubes of the same size and starting mass, made the same way and taken from the freezer at the same moment. Weigh the cubes and keep only those within a gram of each other.
- Drink volume. Pour the same volume, or better, the same mass, into each cup.
- Cup. Use identical cups with the same shape, diameter, material, and fill height. The depth of the liquid affects convection, so a tall narrow glass and a wide tumbler are not equivalent.
- Mixing. Choose one rule and apply it to both cups. Either leave both completely still, or stir both the same way on the same schedule. Stirring is the condition most likely to erase a viscosity difference, so it's worth running both versions.
- Surroundings. Place the cups side by side, out of sunlight and away from drafts, and start them together.
With our Euhomy Tile SE countertop cube ice maker, you can adjust the ice-making time to make thicker or thinner cubes, and one cycle takes about 13 minutes for 16 cubes.
For the test, pick one time setting and take every trial cube from a single batch.
The cleanest way to isolate viscosity is to thicken the same base with a small amount of a neutral thickener, keeping the sugar and temperature the same, rather than comparing two different drinks. Even then, as the Physics Van notes, you'll change more than one property at once, so keep the additions small and the same between cups wherever you can.
How to measure melting: remaining mass of the added cube
The measure that answers the question is how much of the cube you added is still solid.
- Weigh each cube before it goes in. Record the starting mass.
- Use parallel cups for time points. If you want readings at 5, 10, and 20 minutes, set up a separate, identical cup for each time. Lifting one cube out again and again disturbs the flow and adds handling errors.
- Harvest the same way every time. At the set time, lift the cube out with a fork or slotted spoon, press it firmly on all sides against a fresh paper towel for the same short count, and weigh it immediately. Use exactly this procedure for every cube in every cup, thick or thin. A thick base will leave a film you can't fully remove, so the shake cubes will read slightly heavy; note that rather than trying to scrub it off, since extra wiping or rinsing melts the cube or adds water of its own.
- Report the result. Give the remaining mass as a fraction of the starting mass. You can also report the time it takes the cube to reach half its starting mass.
Why not weigh the whole cup?
The meltwater stays in the cup, so the total mass barely changes as the cube melts. Weighing the cup tells you about evaporation and spills, not melting.
Why not judge by taste?
"Watery" is a different question. The drink already contains water. In a shake, its own ice crystals melt and dilute it, whether or not your added cube changes much. Fat, air whipped into the shake, and sweetness also hide dilution to different degrees in different drinks. A shake can taste thinner while the added cube is mostly intact, and juice can taste fine while its cube is half gone. Taste is worth noting, but record it separately from cube mass.
What a result would and wouldn't prove
Suppose you run matched, still cups and the cube in the thicker drink keeps more of its mass. That supports the claim that thickness slowed melting under those conditions: that temperature, that cup, and no stirring. It doesn't tell you how large the effect is in other drinks. And if your thickener also changed density or sugar content, it doesn't fully separate viscosity from those changes.
If the cubes come out about the same, that doesn't prove viscosity never matters. Your drinks may have differed too little in thickness, or your handling may have hidden a small difference.
If you compared two unmatched drinks, like a frozen-fruit protein shake and fridge-cold juice, the result tells you about those two recipes. It doesn't isolate thickness.
Three conditions can turn "thick drinks slow melting" into the wrong explanation: a colder starting drink, a sugary base that layers instead of circulating, and stirring that keeps warm liquid moving past the cube. Check those first, then weigh the cube.




























