Bullet ice is a hollow cylindrical form: a short, smooth-sided piece with one rounded end and an open or dimpled core. "Cylinder ice" isn't a separate product competing with it. It's a loose shape word that can describe a bullet piece, a commercial tube-ice cylinder, or a solid molded cylinder.
So "bullet vs cylinder" isn't a like-for-like performance comparison. You'd be comparing one specific hollow cylinder with a word that might mean that same piece. What you really need to know is which cylinder a listing is selling, and you can usually tell from the wording and one good photo.
How a bullet gets its hollow core
In a typical countertop design, metal pegs sit in a small tray of water and are chilled, so ice builds outward around each peg. When a piece is ready, the pegs warm briefly and the ice slips off into the bin.
That one process explains both features you can see. The rounded, smooth inside was formed against the metal, and the opening runs through the middle because the peg was there. The hollow core is there by design, not a defect. How thick and even the wall around it is, though, is a separate question from whether the piece is hollow. Our ice-shape guides describe bullet ice the same way: forming in hollow cylinders with a rounded tip and often a dimple through the center.
The three things "cylinder ice" can mean

Bullet ice. Grows around a chilled peg. Short, one rounded end, open or dimpled center.
Tube ice. Also a hollow cylinder, but it's made the other way around. According to the FAO, tube ice forms on the inner surface of vertical tubes, with refrigerant surrounding the tubes. A hot-gas defrost releases the ice, and a cutter chops it into lengths as it drops. Both ends are cut flat, and the hole runs straight through.
Solid cylinder. A molded piece with straight sides, flat ends and no core or dimple at all.
Two of these three are hollow, and each is made by a different process. That's why "cylinder" can describe a shape but not tell you how the ice was made.
| What you see | How it formed | Wording to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Rounded end, dimple or open center | Frozen around a chilled peg | "bullet," "bullet-shaped" |
| Flat cut ends, hole straight through | Frozen inside a tube, then cut | "tube ice," hollow cylinder |
| Flat ends, no core | Molded | "mold," "solid," no mention of a hollow center |
Reading a listing without guessing

Start with the shape word, then check it against a photo of a finished piece. A close-up that shows the ends and center matters more than any label. A rounded end with a dimple points to a bullet. Flat ends with a clean hole point to tube ice. Flat ends with no hole point to a solid mold.
To find out what shape a machine makes, first look at the cube description on the product listing, which usually names the shape directly. For example:
Our Euhomy Dart H1 Silver Bullet Ice Maker takes 6 minutes to make 9 bullet-shaped ice cubes.
Then match that wording to a photo of the finished ice, so you know which format you're buying before you decide. Do the same check on any listing in our bullet ice maker collection or elsewhere. If the copy only says "cylinder," look for bullet or tube wording and a photo that shows the core.
Where the loose naming causes buying mistakes
Expecting a different piece. Someone who wants a solid, flat-ended cylinder can end up with bullet ice if a listing calls it "cylinder ice." The photo of the ends would have shown the difference.
Returning ice that's working as designed. If you didn't know bullet ice is hollow, the open center can look like the machine failed. It didn't. That's the shape the peg leaves.
Treating "cylinder" as a grade. The word says nothing about density, clarity or quality. It describes the outline. If one of those matters to you, look for it as its own stated detail.
Rule of thumb
Read "cylinder" as an outline, not a spec. Then look at the ends and the center: a rounded end with a dimple is a bullet, flat ends with a hole are tube ice, and flat ends with no hole are a solid cylinder.




























